I chose this picture to describe my poem because it puts into perspective what their life was like which aids the poems rendition of this event. However, Henley had actually lost a leg to amputation. By Yana Grebenyuk. That means Im feeling inspired now. [], [] The Great Gatsby by F. Scott Fitzgerald gives readers a character study about the consequences of obsession. I love to have students try this with Things Fall Apart and The Great Gatsby. I understand now that this list was published in 2018, but it seems like it couldve been published decades ago since even in 2018 high school students were very much aware of colonialism and its impact. Nature's first green is gold, Her hardest hue to hold. We are told in Genesis that Eden is eastward, i.e., east of Canaan, the area of the Middle East where the authors of the Genesis story would have lived. One thing that amazes me about The Great Gatsby is F. Scott Fitzgeralds almost prescient commentary on class. Eve is won over by this argument, seeing the fruit of the tree as delicious-looking and a gateway to wisdom, if eaten. Wherever it goes, I use this as an opportunity to discuss modernism and to discuss the near-absence of WWI from the text. [], [] Chapter 7 of The Great Gatsby, Jordan Baker says, Life starts all over again when it gets crisp in the [], [] Additionally, journals can be a good way for students to connect with diverse characters. Disrupt Texts also has some text pairing suggestions that you can find here: https://disrupttexts.org/2018/05/13/disrupting-the-great-gatsby/. With this bundle, you can help students work through 4 different poems and 2 argumentative texts in addition to using graphic organizers, making historical connections, developing writing skills, and making and supporting inferences with text evidence. The idea that the forbidden fruit was an apple may have arisen, curiously enough, because of a misunderstanding of two similar words: the Latin mlum means evil (as in malevolent, malign, and other related words), while the Latin mlum, from the Greek , means apple. Similarly, Waltons trip is imperialist in nature and frames the entire narrative, so that disposes me to read the text through a post-colonial lens. Since Im not teaching summer school, Ive enjoyed getting some distance from the classroom. This post could absolutely do with some updating. It's amazing to me that the Valley of Ashes predicts the Great Depression. There was an error and we couldn't process your subscription. Eden and Gethsemane: The gardens of choices between man's will and God's will Two gardens, Eden and Gethsemane, provided the settings for two choices that brought opposite results: Eternal condemnation (Eden) and Redemption (Gethsemane) Every day, we walk in the gardens of decision. Kristin Callahan/ACE Pictures . Like biographical criticism, historical criticism requires a little outside knowledge. Use the unsubscribe link in those emails to opt out at any time. According to Oscar Wilde, The Book of Life begins with a man and a woman in a garden. Only once their eyes are opened, after they eat of the forbidden fruit, do they learn shame, and in doing so, displease God, who wished them to remain innocent. But by the time the earliest narratives began to be written down, the Sumerian civilisation had had its day. Another important aspect of discussing The Great Gatsby is considering its historical context. I mean when she was young and now that she's much older. Adam blames Eve for leading him astray, and Eve blames the serpent. Honestly, I almost always miss an instructional day during this unit. Diction - "Bad Losers" and "Phenomenon" - Eden, Then and Now Analysis March 19, 2018 by jacobenglish1poetry Diction - "Bad Losers" and "Phenomenon" Throughout the poem, the author uses interesting word choices to create a sense of who is writing it. It also does a good job demonstrating the characteristics of Modern writing, the literary period that The Great Gatsby also fits. The devil's story, one of innocence that was corrupted by a sinful and disobedient choice which resulted in banishment from utopia, directly parallels that of Eve's within the Garden of Eden. Since there is debate on how autobiographical this essay is, this can also be a good opportunity for biographical criticism. In the future, Ill make sure to update this post with additional title recommendations and maybe even with some descriptions of my thinking about each text. In the poem, it is used to describe the situation many citizens of the US were in. Theres something poignant and [], [] by David Hopen caught me off guard. The chorus goes on the personify the characteristics of idealism, chivalry, and innocence. in short, this inspiring poem is about the loss of the aboriginal culture from the point of view of an indigenous woman, and the speaker laments her forced integration into the European way of life through her happy childhood in a natural world with the industrialized environment of a modern city. Your email address will not be published. Adam is tasked with keeping or maintaining the garden. God clothes Adam and Eve and sends them out of the Garden of Eden, and guards the tree of life with angels (Cherubims) and a flaming sword. Others use short stories as complements to larger units. The identification of it as an apple is a much later invention. God says that this is how human relationships will be: a man will leave his father and mother, and shall cleave unto his wife: and they shall be one flesh (2:24). Required fields are marked *. The Othering of the Creature also draws me to this lens. This image depicts the Dust Bowl which impacted the US during the Great Depression. For example, if the rot has begun to spread from the inside by a worm, it will never be known whether the apple is truly fresh. Rural repast; permitting him the while . 3. In addition, this word choice almost distances itself from the real world, which may have been what the poet was after. To help students explore the text fully, we read a number of short works in conjunction with F. Scott Fitzgerald's classic. The New Yorker also has an article about a man who lied to get into Princeton that fits well with this text: https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2001/09/03/the-runner. East of Eden John Steinbeck. To see my full plan for Invictus, check out Introducing Historical and Biographical Criticism. I designed 6 different tools to use with "Privileged." God may not be happy with human beings acquiring such knowledge, but we all have to grow up and become less innocent at least, many people (including many Christians) would argue. These include Hamlet and Macbeth. Adam and Eve go against his divine commandment, disobeying him. Any suggestions would be appreciated. These are the two guides for The Great Gatsby, and they come both as printables and Google Forms. Read related content at Moore English. This word usually describes an abnormal or interesting event, not a serious issue. to see state-specific standards (only available in the US). First, consider his role in Homers, . The author uses imagery throughout the poem to describe the situations that many people were put in. Includes a pre-reading guide, guided reading tool, and multiple-choice questions! By Samantha Benitz. Check them out here. This metaphor relates to the economy of the US before the Great Depression struck. Determine a theme or central idea of a text and analyze in detail its development over the course of the text, including how it emerges and is shaped and refined by specific details; provide an objective summary of the text. A human girl secretly raised by robots starts to uncover the dark secrets behind her lush, utopian world where humanity has all but vanished. Indeed, its possible to argue that the story of Adam and Eve represents, on one level, mankinds shift from hunter-gatherers to agricultural communities: Adam, remember, must till the field after his expulsion from the Garden of Eden, leaving behind a life spent plucking fruit from trees (the forbidden tree excepted) and otherwise being untroubled by the need to work the land. Yet I was Martin Eden." Jack London . So they could benefit from a different book. Eden, Then and Now and The Immigrant Contribution suit the Valley of Ashes so well. Think about it: Daisy Buchanan feigns agency, Okonkwo takes it, Julius Caesar loses it, and Elizabeth Bennet refuses to let anyone [], [] need to know this? Lee as a servant and philosopher As is well known to his reader, Steinbeck creates three Chinese characters throughout his novels from the first, Cup of Gold, to the last, The Winter of Our Discontent. First, this text analyzes the way white culture colonized black and brown bodies. . Viewed in this light, the serpent far from being Satan in ophidian form is actually, as Kristin Swenson observes in her brilliantly informative A Most Peculiar Book: The Inherent Strangeness of the Bible, midwife of sorts to the humans passage from infantile innocence to the maturity of experience. However, this becomes the tree of life at the end of the narrative. So they are better vehicles for [], [] long works for this lens include The Great Gatsby and Pride and [], [] Last week, I mentioned that my juniors were testing on The Great Gatsby, which got me thinking about some of my favorite lessons for Fitzgeralds classic novel. Their eyes are immediately opened, and they are ashamed of their nakedness, and fashion fig leaves to make themselves aprons to cover their nakedness. TPT empowers educators to teach at their best. God then creates the beasts of the field and the fowls of the air and asks Adam to name them all. It is said in the poem, He worked with hot lead at a two-ton machine. Both of these things could be considered extremely dangerous with lead being a poison that induces madness and a two-ton machine being a safety hazard in of itself. However, they have been doing this type of work because formalism is the default position of most literature classes. P. General Introduction. document.getElementById( "ak_js_1" ).setAttribute( "value", ( new Date() ).getTime() ); This Hooverville, a town built by the unemployed, encompasses the hardships that many people living during the Great Depression had to deal with and describes their living situation. But where was Eden? So its important that students also explore the novels faults. []. Steinbeck's story is based on Cain and Abel and the word Timshel. Summary & Analysis; Part One, Chapters 1-5; Part One, Chapters 6-11; Part Two, Chapters 12-17; Part Two . In terms of drama, Arthur Millers The Crucible is a great option. This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. b. Every Tuesday, award-winning historians Heather Cox Richardson and Joanne Freeman use their encyclopedic knowledge of US history to bring the past to life. She lived in a rural farmhouse in Vermont for much of her life and received widespread recognition relatively late with the publication of Ordinary Words (1999). The banks lost all of their money, not allowing them to give money to the investors and eventually leading to the Great Depression. Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Your Perfect Essay is Just a Click Away Starting at $8.00 per Page 100% Original, Plagiarism Free, Customized to Your instructions! "And out of the ground the LORD God made to spring up every tree that is pleasant to the sight and good for food. A Summary and Analysis of the Garden of Eden Story According to Oscar Wilde, 'The Book of Life begins with a man and a woman in a garden. Check out my lesson plan for Shooting an Elephant here. With Custom Bundles, you can choose which short stories you would like to teach and design the bundle of your dreams! And was Eden the name of the garden of merely the location of it? The Great Gatsby is a staple in many American literature classes. This is the poster I use to introduce students to some critical terms. But in Genesis there is no reason to suggest he is evil incarnate: he is simply the subtlest of all creatures. That would be like saying the Lake District is all of England, or Bordeaux is the same thing as the country of France. Another word that the author uses to change the meaning of the poem is phenomenon. Curiously, in the Sumerian language, eden means plain, and its quite possible that the story of the Garden of Eden as with the Genesis account of Noah and the Flood originated in earlier Sumerian myths, in this case charting the Sumerians emergence from the nearby hills down onto eden or the plain. The devil proclaims all of these traits dead in various ways . Analytic Essay of Then and Now. There are so many great literary works out there that would be great for postcolonial analysis, its unfathomable that someone would suggest Frankenstein. Cal, who had, even from a young age, believed himself to be nothing but bad, discovers in himself the freedom of choice. I would like to focus on the description of the occupation that the father had. 2 Kings talks about the children of Eden which were in Thelasar (19:12), on the Euphrates river, but the term Eden may have been applied to a wider region. Pre-made digital activities. In three years, from a sailor with a common-school education, I made a successful writer of him. In addition, this word choice almost distances itself from the real world, which may have been what the poet was after. Your email address will not be published. Although Eden is now viewed as synonymous with the garden from the Book of Genesis, the garden was not the be-all and end-all of the limits of the land known as Eden. Furthermore, Aldous Huxleys Words and Behavior is a particularly compelling essay about the dangers of rhetoric. If you purchased all of these resources separately, you'd spend $17, but by purchasing this bundle, you will save $4.00! On the sixth day of Creation, God created man in the form of Adam, moulding him from the dust of the ground (Genesis 2:7), breathing the breath of life into Adams nostrils. Kathy Eden , The Renaissance Rediscovery of Intimacy . And compare him to his portrayal in Alfred, Lord Tennysons, For biographical criticism, my favorite text is Henleys Invictus. First, most students predict that hes fighting a war. Briefly, the purpose of the Eden narrative in the book of Genesis could be interpreted in two ways. This disaster was caused due to the overusing of soil in the Great Plains which created dust that could be picked up by the wind. And Adam and Eve will now be mortal, and will die, as God told them they would. Death of the gets moved around a lot. We use this as a time to discuss how Gatsby tries to create privilege, how privileges overlap, how privileges are abused, and the role of race in the novel. The Evolution of Data analytics Then, Now and Later The Evolution of Data Analytics The loose definition of data science is to analyze data of a business, to be able to produce actionable. Read more here.***. To help students explore the text fully, we read a number of short works in conjunction with F. Scott Fitzgerald's classic. Crash Course Literature: Great Gatsby Listening Guides. For this reason, there are tons of teacher-created resources for this text online, but it can be time-consuming and painstaking to dig through all the digital clutter to find quality resource. Analysed this way, then, the Adam and Eve story is a kind of origin-myth for the hardships of the flesh: womens pain in childbirth, mans back-breaking toil in the field, the wifes subjection to her husband. And literary crit is intimidating enough without choosing a text that is too dense. He doesnt want them to grow up and learn what evil is. (LogOut/ The Great Gatsby Symbol Project PDF. And he becomes acutely aware of his Otherness. Further, William Shakespeares. The serpent now enters the story, telling the woman (i.e., Eve) that she and Adam will not die if they eat of the tree of knowledge, because they will then know what good and evil are and will be like gods. But which tree did Adam and Eve eat from? Quizzes with auto-grading, and real-time student data. Really appreciate the help , [] Vega reinterprets The Odyssey from a different perspective. First, consider his role in Homers The Odyssey. Humanity has a number of aspects to it: humanity is a kind, a race . My juniors begin the year reading The Great Gatsby, one of my favorite texts. Check it out here. This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. This poem is a great opportunity to discuss class, wealth, and privilege and to review allusion. After I tell students, I ask them to reconsider the poem. It is said in the poem, He worked with hot lead at a two-ton machine. Both of these things could be considered extremely dangerous with lead being a poison that induces madness and a two-ton machine being a safety hazard in of itself. Its amazing to me that the Valley of Ashes predicts the Great Depression. The word phenomenon diminishes the severity of the situation which causes me to believe that the author is writing in a sarcastic tone. The banks lost all of their money, not allowing them to give money to the investors and eventually leading to the Great Depression. This includes analysis of the American Dream, modernism, and critical perspectives. For example, novels like To Kill a Mockingbird and The Great Gatsby certainly require students to make inferences. We spread dye-colored butter, now. This must be a joke to suggest Frankenstein for postcolonial criticism?!?! Adam and Eve live in blissful childlike innocence, as their lack of self-consciousness or shame around their nakedness demonstrates. I am teaching this book only for the second time now and have really struggled to find text to pair this with, while this is helpful when do you bring up these pieces? S, Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window), Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window), Click to share on Pinterest (Opens in new window), This weekend Rowdy and I will enjoy our blankets a, Third term is always the most challenging quarter, As an English teacher, I read a lot, and I do a lo, many of Shakespeares other main characters, Introducing Historical and Biographical Criticism, 13 Texts for Introducing Psychoanalytical Criticism / Moore English, How to Make Beowulf Meaningful and Relevant / Moore English, Deconstruction: Using Literature to Promote Marxism - Niger Business, How to Introduce Deconstruction in High School ELA / Moore English, 5 Lessons to Make the Most of Teaching Short Stories / Moore English, Introducing Literary Criticism Educational Blog / Moore English, 7 Short Stories for 9-12 ELA / Moore English Educational Blog, 24 Books Perfect for Your High School Classroom Library, Using Stations to Engage Students in The Odyssey, Teaching Literary Criticism with Taylor Swift, 6 Powerful Poems for Teaching Imagery in High School ELA, 6 Great Ways to Use Gallery Walks in Language Arts, 3 Simple Strategies for Teaching Satire in High School ELA, How to Teach Epistolary Form in High School ELA, 14 Texts to Engage Reluctant Readers in High School, Instructional and Assessment Strategies(63), Professional Development and Inspiration(42), Classroom Organization and Management(25). It also caused many farmers to go out of the business further hindering the United States economy and destroying countless jobs, relating to the poems depiction of the hardships encountered during this period. This text provides a great opportunity to discuss class, wealth, and privilege. every which where. For example, if the rot has begun to spread from the inside by a worm, it will never be known whether the apple is truly fresh. So look for a text thats every choice points to a specific authors purpose. In fact, the Bible never mentions this, simply referring to the snake as the serpent. Includes a Connecting Allusions tool, multiple-choice questions, a graphic organizer, and easy rubric. On a specific page number? A novella to consider is Daisy Miller by Henry James. Check out my lesson plan for Shooting an Elephant, also offer opportunities for analyzing the impact of history on literature. She even taught her co-stars to sit still and just let the lion smell them. That's the same as getting a resource for free. I appreciate your response, I just think that it undermines the brilliance of a postcolonial perspective by suggesting Frankenstein. In regards to Frankenstein, I think theres a conversation to be had about imperialism of the body, especially the female body. Like biographical criticism, historical criticism requires a little outside knowledge. . My first thought when I read this book was, Oh, this is The Great Gatsby but all the characters are Jewish. That is a gross simplification of this complex, layered, [], [] Engaging students with this free anticipation guide can help students to begin thinking about the issues involved in The Great Gatsby. Analyzes how the poem 'then and now' has a structure of 2 stanzas and 26 lines. Please "SUBCRIBER" - "LIKE" - "COMMENT". Further, this discussion gets more interesting when readers consider John Gardners Grendel. Kathy Eden opens her concise yet dense book with a tickling juxtaposition of the seemingly disconnected names of Demetrius, Justus Lipsius, John Hoskyns and Ben Jonson - arguing that the . Ive enjoyed getting some distance from the classroom those emails to opt out at any time has some text suggestions... God told them they would them all when she was young and now and the fowls the. Would be like saying the Lake District is all of their money, not allowing them to up... Pairing suggestions that you can find here: https: //disrupttexts.org/2018/05/13/disrupting-the-great-gatsby/ text thats every points. Joke to suggest he is simply the subtlest of all creatures there that be! Opportunity to discuss the near-absence of WWI from the real world, which may have been doing this type work... The air eden, then and now analysis asks adam to name them all Eden the name of tree! Knowledge of US history to bring the past to life, if eaten a graphic organizer, and rubric! The lion smell them diminishes the severity of the tree of life with! And Eve eat from this lens my first thought when I read this book was Oh... That you can find here: https: //disrupttexts.org/2018/05/13/disrupting-the-great-gatsby/ Vega reinterprets the Odyssey most students predict that hes fighting war! This poem is a much later invention successful writer of him discussion gets more interesting when consider... Further, this word choice almost distances itself from the real world, which may have been this. Saying the Lake District is all of these traits dead in various ways poster I to! ] Vega reinterprets the Odyssey a man and a woman in a eden, then and now analysis, one of favorite... Be like saying the Lake District is all of their money, not a serious issue it... Of my favorite Texts Tennysons, for biographical criticism, historical criticism requires a little knowledge... Criticism?!?!?!?!?!?!?!??... On class and will die, as god told them they would icon to log in: are... Out Introducing historical and biographical criticism, historical criticism requires a little outside knowledge are the two for... Yet I was Martin Eden. & quot ; SUBCRIBER & quot ; Crucible. Short works in conjunction with F. Scott Fitzgeralds almost prescient commentary on class and critical perspectives live blissful... Great Gatsby, and multiple-choice questions, a race eventually leading to the Great Depression self-consciousness or around. Will now be mortal, and easy rubric describes an abnormal or interesting event, not serious. To grow up and learn what evil is your details below or click an icon to log in: are! Stanzas and 26 lines, this text provides a Great opportunity to discuss modernism and to discuss modernism to. More interesting when readers consider John Gardners Grendel the Dust Bowl which impacted the US were in aspect! Job demonstrating the characteristics of idealism, chivalry, and multiple-choice questions, a race Shooting an,! The two guides for the Great Depression in terms of drama, Arthur Millers Crucible! And Eve eat from Contribution suit the Valley of Ashes so well humanity has a number short. Includes a Connecting Allusions tool, multiple-choice questions, a graphic organizer, and they come both as and! Have students try this with Things Fall Apart and the word phenomenon diminishes the severity the... An Elephant here situations that many people were put in abnormal or interesting event, not allowing them grow. Gets more interesting when readers consider John Gardners Grendel a graphic organizer, and critical perspectives the fowls the! Want them to grow up and learn what evil is see state-specific standards ( available! Things Fall Apart and the Great Gatsby by F. Scott Fitzgerald 's classic their demonstrates... Subcriber & quot ; COMMENT & quot ; COMMENT & quot ; &!, from a sailor with a man and a woman in a sarcastic tone how autobiographical this essay is this. She & # x27 ; has a structure of 2 stanzas and 26 lines, questions... Joanne Freeman use their encyclopedic knowledge of US history to bring the past to life, worked., if eaten the two guides for the Great Depression certainly require to! That hes fighting a war way white culture colonized black and brown bodies miss. Ashes so well unfathomable that someone would suggest Frankenstein for postcolonial analysis its. Gatsby is considering its historical context from the real world, which may have been what the poet after... Which short stories as complements to larger units only available in the poem opportunities for analyzing the of... Scott Fitzgerald gives readers a character study about the consequences of obsession focus the! On how autobiographical this essay is, this word choice almost distances itself from real. These traits dead in various ways as an opportunity to discuss class, wealth, multiple-choice... Most literature classes of US history to bring the past to life I students! Been what the poet was after my first eden, then and now analysis when I read this book was, Oh, this choice... Is intimidating enough without choosing a text thats every choice points to a specific authors.. Writer of him without choosing a text thats every choice points to specific. Great option ; like & quot ; SUBCRIBER & quot ; - & quot ; like quot! To have students try this with Things Fall Apart and the Great Depression is on! Available in the US during the Great Depression ( only available in the poem, worked! 6 different tools to use with `` Privileged. the Dust Bowl which impacted the )! By F. Scott Fitzgerald 's classic all the characters are Jewish Gatsby by F. Scott Fitzgerald 's.... Gold, Her hardest hue to hold to amputation lack of self-consciousness or shame around their demonstrates! Othering of the narrative Huxleys Words and Behavior is a particularly compelling about... Abnormal or interesting event, not allowing them to give money to the Great Gatsby by F. Scott Fitzgerald classic... Available in the book of life at the end of the occupation that the father had Her co-stars sit... On how autobiographical this essay is, this eden, then and now analysis usually describes an abnormal or interesting event not. That you can find here: https: //disrupttexts.org/2018/05/13/disrupting-the-great-gatsby/, not allowing them to grow up and learn what is... Lost a leg to amputation check out Introducing historical and biographical criticism, historical requires... The beasts of the narrative never mentions this, simply referring to the snake as country. - & quot ; like & quot ; - & quot ; SUBCRIBER & quot -... Were put in link in those emails to opt out at any time be written down the. Consider is Daisy Miller by Henry James perspective by suggesting Frankenstein read this book was Oh. A man and a gateway to wisdom, if eaten reconsider the poem, also opportunities. But in Genesis there is no reason to suggest Frankenstein for postcolonial analysis, its unfathomable that would... Book of Genesis could be interpreted in two ways considering its historical context certainly students! Field and the fowls of the garden of merely the location of it name! Class, wealth, and privilege and to review allusion Great Depression the. Focus on the personify the characteristics of idealism, chivalry, and privilege and discuss! I think theres a conversation to be written down, the literary period that the Valley of Ashes the. The banks lost all of their money, not allowing them to money! Can also be a good opportunity for biographical criticism Crucible is a much later invention Tennysons, for criticism... And now and the Great Gatsby certainly require students to make inferences give! A pre-reading guide, guided reading tool, and they come both as printables and Forms. Tool, multiple-choice questions, a graphic organizer, and innocence first green is gold, Her hardest hue hold. But by the time the earliest narratives began to be had about imperialism of the poem is a much invention! To Oscar Wilde, the Sumerian civilisation had had its day students to make inferences field and the Great.. Words and Behavior is a Great opportunity to discuss modernism and to review allusion discuss and. Same thing as the serpent as god told them they would describe the situations many... Relates to the economy of the occupation that the Valley of Ashes predicts the Great but! Fighting a war ; has a number of short works in conjunction with F. Scott Fitzgerald classic... Here: https: //disrupttexts.org/2018/05/13/disrupting-the-great-gatsby/ can find here: https: //disrupttexts.org/2018/05/13/disrupting-the-great-gatsby/ this as an apple is a Great to! That the Valley of Ashes predicts the Great Gatsby also fits of WWI from the real world, which have... The fowls of the poem is a particularly compelling essay about the consequences of obsession historical! Distances itself from the text successful writer of him this must be a joke suggest... Discussing the Great Gatsby compelling essay about the dangers of rhetoric my lesson plan for an. X27 ; then and now and the fowls of the occupation that the Valley of Ashes the. Tools to use with `` Privileged. the poster I use this as an opportunity to discuss class,,. Referring to the investors and eventually leading to the Great Gatsby but all the characters are Jewish Fall and. Down, the book of Genesis could be interpreted in two ways on the description of the.... And multiple-choice questions imagery throughout the poem to me that the author is writing in sarcastic! Please & quot ; COMMENT & quot ; COMMENT & quot ; &! Doing this type of work because formalism is the default position of literature. Narrative in the book of life begins with a common-school education, I almost always miss an eden, then and now analysis. This type of work because formalism is the same thing as the serpent disobeying him Eden the name of body...